Every Airbnb review breaks into six category scores: cleanliness, accuracy, check-in, communication, location, and value. Ask most hosts where they focus, and the answer is cleanliness. It is the one they can control, the one that stings when it slips, and the one every cleaning checklist is built around. The data suggests that is not where the next dollar hides.
We looked at 40,087 active US listings and asked a simple question for each category: do the listings scoring near-perfect (4.9 and up) actually earn more than the ones scoring low (under 4.7), comparing only against homes of the same size in the same ZIP code? Same market, same size, different scores. The figures below come from our own research, not a third-party report. Here is how the six ranked by how closely each one tracks with revenue:
- Communication: +10%
- Accuracy: +8%
- Location: +6%
- Check-in: +5%
- Cleanliness: +4%
- Value: +1%
Two things stand out.
Communication tops the list. The category that is purely about how you show up, meaning fast replies, clear answers, and setting expectations, tracks revenue more closely than any other. Accuracy sits right behind it: does the place match what the listing promised? Together they say something plain. Guests reward the hosts who communicate well and describe honestly, and they reward them more than the ones with the shiniest floors.
Value comes dead last. A high value score feels like a win, but it barely tracks with revenue, and the reason makes sense once you say it out loud. “Great value” often just means “cheaper than it should have been.” A perfect value score can be a quiet sign that you are leaving money on the table.
Before you act on this, three honest caveats. First, this is correlation, not a lever you crank; a higher score does not mechanically print revenue. Second, nearly every active listing scores between 4.8 and 5.0 on these categories, so what you are really seeing is the gap between the top performers and the stragglers, not a wide spread. Third, location is not something you can fix. A strong location score just means you have a good location.
Strip those out, and you are left with a useful shortlist. The categories that track most closely with revenue, communication, accuracy, and check-in, are also the ones you can actually change, and they cost nothing but attention.
Communication is the fastest to move. Answer quickly, since Airbnb already rewards response time in ranking. Save templated replies for the questions you get over and over. Send a message before arrival that sets expectations instead of waiting for the guest to ask.
Accuracy is about honesty, not polish. Update your photos when the space changes, and describe the quirks plainly: the steep stairs, the street that gets loud on weekends, the kitchen that is smaller than it looks. Guests do not punish an honest description. They punish a surprise.
Check-in is usually a systems problem. Clear instructions, a lock that works every time, and a short message with directions and parking will move it.
Cleanliness still matters. It is just table stakes now. Everyone is already near-perfect, so scrubbing for one more decimal point is not where the growth is. Hit the bar and move your energy to the categories that actually separate you.
And that last-place value score is worth a second look for a different reason. If guests keep telling you the place is a great value, they may be telling you your price is too low. The review that feels like a compliment can be the one costing you the most. Watching which scores are slipping, and what your pricing should be doing about it, is the kind of thing analytics and pricing tools track for you. That is the space IntelliHost works in, and there are others.
Which of your six category scores is weakest, and is it one you can actually fix?
Disclosure: I’m the founder of IntelliHost, which builds traffic-based pricing and analytics for short-term rental operators. If you’d like your listing’s review, click, and conversion data turned into pricing and listing decisions automatically, you can see how it works at intellihost.co, or connect with me on LinkedIn.
.webp)
